As I'm in the process of creating a Zine and using the first issue as my final major project, I'll be analyzing many a zine on here. This is essentially to show my research to my tutors who read this, but also for my own understandings and to learn from the best and the worst.
So, first zine is . . . .

There's no doubt that Tough Crowd is exceptionally well made. At the 'Self Publish and Be Damned' fair in London this was no doubt the most professional looking zine. It ticked all the boxes, colour print, high quality glossy paper, professionally stapled and cut etc.
However, the main dilemma with zines is that they are something that has been born out of passion, and should have a voice and personality that distinguish them, and this was the one thing that lacked. Despite some great interviews with interesting and more importantly, actual known figures such as Bruce LaBruce and Matthew Stone, the issue lacked any kind of voice or personality. This was mostly due to their clear need for professional appearance. Something like an editor's note would have been a great inclusion for what is basically intending on being a mini-magazine.
The editorial included also bears the same problem with the personal/professional dilemma. While being well-executed, photographed and styled, it doesn't seem to have any narrative function or major personality. The clothes have great shapes but are rendered bland by the ivy garden background.
A stronger point is that the articles are a really good length. The longest one that borders on being dense however, has been cramped into a fairly packed article. This is mainly down to font size and page layout, as it could have done with breaking up a little. I'm not quibbling about long articles at all though, if anything they should be included more!
The idea of theming each issue is one that also worries me. i.D magazine I felt took it too far and just went theme-crazy every issue (the day Leona Lewis was on the cover was the last straw), so it's dodgy territory. They've managed to work it really well though I feel, and it doesn't at all feel gimmicky, and instead well thought out, and the cover reflects it well.
The whole issue is up online on their website, which looks great using 'Issuu' as a pdf viewer. Without wanting to digress too much, i believe if you are going to have the whole zine available in high res online for free, it needs to be something extra special to want to pay for the printed version, so great design, collectibility, photography and illustration are a MUST.
I feel incredibly harsh for saying all the negatives above as it is still a great zine and still worthy of buying, it just seems to lack a certain presence. It's a problem many face in the quest for professionalism, they lose the voice that prompted the thing in the first place.